The Rinehart Center for Reproductive Medicine

Recurrent Pregnancy Loss

 

Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Post (After)-Implantation

What is post-implantation pregnancy loss?

Post-implantation pregnancy losses are manifest as early or late pregnancy losses Early pregnancy losses are losses of embryos during the first trimester of pregnancy and have been termed miscarriages. Although many advances in reproductive medicine have been made during the past 25 years, miscarriages remain the most common complication of pregnancy. While most miscarriages are sporadic and not repetitive, there is a subset of couples that suffer recurrent miscarriage. While the risk of miscarriage increases with maternal age, overall 15% of pregnancies miscarry. Approximately 13% of all recognized first pregnancies are lost. The risk of a second consecutive miscarriage is only slightly increased to 17%. However the risk of miscarriage after two consecutive pregnancy losses rises to 35 to 40% and continues to rise with each subsequent miscarriage. As many as 5% of all couples conceiving experience two consecutive miscarriages and 2% have three or more losses. Late pregnancy losses are losses of fetuses after the first trimester of pregnancy. Late pregnancy losses occur far less frequently than early pregnancy losses and comprise only 1% of pregnancies. Late pregnancy losses are usually associated with incompetent cervix, premature rupture of membranes, preterm labor, intrauterine growth retardation or placental abruption.

What are the causes of recurrent post-implantation pregnancy loss?

Historically, the cause of recurrent post-implantation pregnancy loss was unknown in most couples. More recently, however, much progress has been made in understanding the mechanisms involved. Just as with pre-implantation and peri-implantation pregnancy loss, two major reasons for repeat post-implantation pregnancy loss exist. One is that there is something wrong with the pregnancy itself, such as a chromosomal abnormality that prohibits the pregnancy from implanting or growing properly. The other reason is a problem within in environment in which the pregnancy grows that does not allow an otherwise normal embryo to implant or grow properly. Problems within the uterine environment or lining of the uterus have been classified as anatomic, hormonal and immunologic.

Problems with the Pregnancy - Problems with the pregnancy are usually characterized by the presence of an abnormal chromosome of the conceptus. Chromosomal abnormalities occur in about 50% of all products of conception from first trimester miscarriages, 5% of late pregnancy losses and 0.5% of live births. When products of conception from over 200 miscarriages of women with repeat pregnancy loss were tested with chromosomal analysis, 55% were abnormal. Of interest, only 35% of women experiencing recurrent pregnancy loss after a live birth were chromosomally abnormal. Some pregnancy losses associated with abnormal chromosomes such as an extra chromosome (trisomy) have been reported to have a high risk of a repeating. However, if such “accidents” explained all of recurrent miscarriage, the probability of three or more miscarriages in a row resulting from “accidents” would account for 5% or less of the observed incidence of losses. Biochemical or clinical abortion occurs in 30%-40% of women who achieve pregnancy after IVF and ET. Statistically, greater than 80% of transfers of three preimplantation embryos should include at least one normal karyotypic preimplantation embryo. Furthermore, it has been estimated that 75% of karyotypically normal preimplantation embryos fail to implant. Therefore, while chromosomal abnormalities play a major role in earlier pregnancy losses, other causes account for most late pregnancy losses as well as around half of miscarriages and occult losses.

A number of studies have reported observations suggesting the existence of paternal (sperm derived) effect on human embryo quality and pregnancy outcome that are not reflected as a chromosomal abnormality. Damaged sperm DNA can have a negative impact on fetal development and present clinically as occult or early clinical miscarriage. The Sperm DNA Integrity assay (SDIa) serves as a tool for measuring important properties of sperm chromatin integrity.

Problems with the Uterine Environment - Problems within the environment in which the embryo implants and fetus grows have been classified as anatomic, hormonal and immunologic. While anatomic and hormonal abnormalities have been associated with pre-implantation pregnancy losses, there roles in post-implantation pregnancy loss have been controversial. The mechanism of the losses in post-implantation pregnancy failures seems to involve clotting off the small placental vessels so that the pregnancy “withers on the vine”. Clotting of these vessels can be caused by:

  1. proteins or cytokines that are produced by immunologic cells within the lining of the uterus or
  2. by antiphospholipid antibodies produced by circulating immune B cells or
  3. by a genetic predisposition contributed by thrombophilia genes.

Cytokines

Miscarriages can be caused by cytokines or proteins secreted by cells within the uterus. The activity of these cytokines has been characterized as pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory. While initial exposure to pro-inflammatory cytokines is necessary to stimulate invasion of the blastocyst and formation of new blood vessels at the time of implantation, prolonged exposure of pro-inflammatory cytokines to the pregnancy is detrimental. Thus, for pregnancy to be successful a change in balance of secretion of cytokines from pro-inflammatory to anti-inflammatory cytokines must occur. Three major types of immune cells within the lining of the uterus contribute to the pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory responses: T cells, NK cells and macrophages. Macrophages and NK cells infiltrate implantation sites destined to miscarry. Both of these cells are sources of pro-inflammatory cytokines that can activate production of the prothrombinase, fgl2. Fgl2 leads to deposition of fibrin (a clotting factor) and activation of another white blood cell called polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMN) that can destroy the vascular supply to the placenta. Blood supply to the embryo is compromised and the pregnancy essentially withers on the vine. Increased expression of fgl2 has been shown association with miscarriage of chromosomally normal embryos as contrasted with chromosomally abnormal embryos.

Antiphospholipid Antibodies

Antiphospholipid antibodies (APA) have been shown to be associated with pregnancy loss (both early and late). The action of APA on the blood vessel cells results in blood clotting within the vessels and thus blood supply to the pregnancy is impaired. While testing for anticardiolipins (cardiolipins are a kind of phospholipid) is standard in some infertility clinics, this test alone cannot identify the presence of all underlying autoimmune processes that causes recurrent pregnancy loss. A panel of tests for antibodies to six additional phospholipids is recommended to determine the presence of APA. Testing positive for one or more kind of antiphospholipid antibodies indicates the woman has the immune response that can causes recurrent pregnancy loss. Of the antiphospholipid antibodies tested, antiphosphoserine, choline, glycerol, inositol and ethanolamine have been shown to target the preimplantation embryo; antiphosphoserine and ethanolamine to target placental cells; and antiphosphoserine, ethanolamine and cardiolipin to target blood vessel cells.

Because some circumstances can cause false positives for these tests, it is important to determine persistent positive levels by repeating the tests in six to eight weeks.

The live birth rate for a patient with untreated APA ranges from 11 percent to 20 percent. Individuals with recurrent pregnancy loss and/or implantation failure, venous or arterial, thrombosis, thrombocytopenia, elevated APTT or a circulating lupus-like anticoagulant are among those at risk for development of APA. Also at risk may be women experiencing infertility associated with endometriosis, premature ovarian failure, multiple failed in-vitro fertilization, and unexplained infertility. With treatment, the live birth rate for women with APA increases to 70 to 80 percent.

Thrombophilia Panel

Thrombophilia or blood clotting can be both acquired or inherited. The most common cause of acquired thrombophilia is antiphospholipid antibodies. Inherited thrombophilias can result from gene mutations involved in coagulation. A number of genes involved in blood clotting have been shown to be associated with abnormal clotting and a history of thrombosis. Deficiencies of antithrombin III, protein S or C are usually associated with a previous history of blood clots or thromboses. Other gene mutations or “changes” are not associated with such a high risk of blood clots, but are associated with recurrent pregnancy loss. These include Factor V von Leiden, Factor II Prothrombin, Fibrinogen, Factor XIII), fibrinolysis (PAI-1) and thrombosis (Human Platelet Antigen-1, Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase gene mutations. All of these mutations have been associated more with second and third trimester loss than first trimester loss. However, it appears the more mutations you have, the higher the risk for early pregnancy loss. In one study, about 8 percent of women with a history of recurrent miscarriage had combined thrombophilic defects compared with 1 percent of controls.

How can we determine the cause of recurrent peri-implantation pregnancy losses?

There are a number of tests mentioned in the above description of the cause of recurrent post-implantation pregnancy loss that are available to diagnose post-implantation pregnancy failure. These are listed below in alphabetical order.

  • Activated Reproductive Immunophenotype - The Activated Reproductive Immunophenotype measures not only the percentage of circulating lymphocytes as the Reproductive Immunophenotype does, but also activated NK and T cells. Women experiencing implantation failure after IVF/ET have significantly higher expression of NK cell activation marker of CD69+ and of T cell activation marker of HLA-DR.
  • Antinuclear Antibodies - The presence of ANA indicates there may be an underlying autoimmune process that affects the clotting off of the placenta and can lead to early pregnancy loss.
  • Antiphospholipid Antibodies - Antiphospholipid antibodies have a direct action on the blood vessel to cause clotting.
  • Antithyroid Antibodies - Women with thyroid antibodies face double the risk of miscarriage as women without them. Increased levels of thyroglobulin and thyroid microsomal (thyroid peroxidase) autoantibodies show a relationship in an increased miscarriage rate, and as many as 31 percent of women experiencing RSA are positive for one or both antibodies. Chances of a loss in the first trimester of pregnancy increase to 20 percent, and there is also an increased risk of post-partum thyroid dysfunction.
  • Embryotoxicity Assay - The embryotoxicity assay (ETA) is looking measures substances in blood that kill embryos. Embryotoxic factors have been identified in as many as 60 percent of women with recurrent, unexplained miscarriage, and also reported among women endometriosis-associated infertility.
  • HLA G Testing - The major histocompatability complex (MHC), well known for its role in the regulation of cell-cell interaction in the immune response, also influences reproductive success. The MHC affects a variety of reproductive parameters including spontaneous abortion, protection of fetus from attack by the maternal immune system and regulation of preimplantation embryo growth and survival. One gene in the MHC has that has had special attention with respect to reproduction is the class I gene HLA-G because it is important in establishing immunotolerance of the pregnancy. Mutations in the HLA gene could interfere with this vital process, resulting in pregnancy loss.
  • Immunoglobulin Panel - Hypogammaglobulinemia of IgA needs to be further evaluated to rule out IgA antibodies before treatment with intravenous immunoglobulin is considered.
  • Inhibin B - Inhibin-B serum concentration provides a new measure of ovarian reserve and, as such, can predict risk for chromsosomal abnormalies among eggs.
  • Lupus-like Anticoagulant - About four percent of women with recurrent miscarriage test positive for lupus-like anticoagulant, and nine percent of individuals diagnosed with SLE have a positive lupus anticoagulant test, or activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT). APTT is an adequate screening test for lupus-like anticoagulant antibodies, but there is a high incidence of false positives. Women who have a positive APTT should also have more specific tests, such as Kaolin clotting time, Russel viper venom assay and the platelet neutralization assay a to confirm the presence of lupus anticoagulant antibody activity. And, since some women do not test positive until they are pregnant or have suffered a pregnancy loss, repeat testing during early pregnancy is highly recommended when there is a history of recurrent post0implantation pregnancy loss.
  • Natural Killer Activity - Natural Killer cell activity or activation assay (NKa) measures the killing activity (cytotoxicity) within each cell. Increased killing activity is associated with implantation failure and pregnancy loss. A value of greater than 105 killing with a target to effector ratio of 1:50 is considered abnormal. The NKa also measures the ability of IVIg to suppress the killing activity. Patients with high NK cell activity that suppress with IVIg in the NKa will respond very well to intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) therapy. In fact, the live birth rate with preconception IVIg is more than 80 percent, compared to 20 percent without treatment.
  • Reproductive Immunophenotype - White blood cells that belong to the innate or primitive immune system kill anything perceived as foreign . Some types of NK cells produce a substance called tumor necrosis factor (TNF), which might be described as your body's version of chemotherapy, and is toxic to a developing fetus. Patients who have high levels of these cells are at risk for implantation failure and miscarriage. The proportion of NK cells is determined by a reproductive immunophenotype (RIP) test, which looks for cells that have the CD56+ marker. An NK (CD56+) cell range above 12 percent is abnormal.
  • Sperm DNA Integrity Assay - Results of recent research indicate that sperm influences not only rates of fertilization of eggs but also subsequent embryo development. The markers of sperm quality used to predict pregnancy outcome are not the parameters included in the standard semen analysis (sperm concentration, motility or morphology) but rather the results of the Sperm DNA Integrity assay, which measures the amount of sperm DNA that is fragmented. A sperm DNA fragmentation index of greater than 30% is associated with poor fertility potential.
  • Thrombophilia Panel - Thrombophilia is defined as a predisposition for thrombosis. Increased thrombosis can result from defects in coagulation, fibrinolysis, platelet aggregation and endothelial damage. About 40% of patients with thrombosis are inherited. Inherited thrombophilias have been associated with early and late recurrent pregnancy loss. Obstetrical complications such as intrauterine growth retardation, placental abruption as well as preeclampsia have also been related to abnormal placental vasculature. Genetic thrombophilia are suspected to account for about 30% of these obstetrical complications. Poor pregnancy outcomes are associated with maternal thrombophilia but may also be associated with fetal thrombophilia by inheritance of maternal and paternal thrombophilic genes. Because hemostasis involves not only blood clotting but also dissolution of the clot once formed and damage to the blood vessel wall, the Thrombophilia Panel contains gene muations for 10 genes involved in all aspects of normal hemostasis, not just the usual 3 performed in commericial laboratories.
  • Y Chromosome Microdeletion Assay Related to Recurrent Pregnancy Loss (MYC/RPL) - While Y chromosome deletions were initially reported to be associated with infertility due to low or no sperm counts, more recent research has shown a site in the proximal AZFc region of the Y chromosome to be microdeleted among men whose partners experienced recurrent pregnancy loss. The four sites analyzed for deletions are DYS262, DYS220, DYF85S1, DYF86F1.

How can we treat recurrent post-implantation pregnancy loss?

Effective treatment depends on the cause of the pregnancy loss. If the cause of the pregnancy loss is a problem within the embryo itself, elimination of the problem involves treatments including donor egg, donor sperm or IVF with preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). If, however, the cause is related to activated immune cells and their cytokines, treatments include: Intravenous Immunoglobulin (IVIg), Intralipid, and Phosphodiesterase Inhibitors. If either acquired or inherited thrombophilia is causing clotting of the placental vessel and subsequent pregnancy loss, then heparin and aspirin is the treatment of choice. If the blood clotting is the result of an immune process, then steroids and/or IVIg can be used.

1. Intravenous Immunoglobulin (IVIg)

IVIg has been used to treat pre-implantation, peri-implantation and post-implantation recurrent pregnancy loss associated with elevated levels of antiphospholipid antibodies, antithyroid antibodies, circulating NK cells and NK cell killing activity and embryotoxins. It has also been used for treatment of unexplained recurrent pregnancy loss. The mechanisms by which IVIg works include:

  • IVIg provides antibodies to antibodies (anti-idiotypic antibodies)
  • IVIg suppresses B cells production of autoantibodies
  • IVIg enhances regulatory T cell activity
  • IVIg suppresses NK cell killing activity

Originally, IVIg therapy was used to treat women who had not been successful in pregnancies previously treated with aspirin and prednisone or heparin. The rationale for the use of IVIG in the original studies was the suppression of the lupus anticoagulant in a woman being treated for severe thrombocytopenia. IVIg was often given with prednisone or heparin plus aspirin. The estimated success rate of 71% for women at very high risk for failure with a history of previous treatment failures suggested IVIg treatment was effective. More recently, IVIg therapy alone has been used to successfully treat women with antiphospholipid antibodies as well as women who become refractory to conventional autoimmune treatment with heparin or prednisone and aspirin.

Proinflammatory cytokines at the maternal-fetal surface can cause clotting of the placental vessels and subsequent pregnancy loss. One source of these cytokines is the NK cell. Biopsies of the lining of the uterus from women experiencing repeat pregnancy loss reveal an increase in activated NK cells. Peripheral blood NK cells are also elevated in women with repeat pregnancy loss compared with women without a history of pregnancy loss. Measurement of NK cells in peripheral blood of women with a history of recurrent miscarriage and a repeated failing pregnancy has shown a significant elevation associated with loss of a normal karyotypic pregnancy and a normal level associated with loss of embryos that are karyotypically abnormal. Furthermore, increased NK activity in the blood of nonpregnant women is predictive of recurrence of pregnancy loss. Suppressor T cells with are required for protection against NK cytokine-dependent pregnancy loss. IVIg has been shown to decrease NK killing activity and enhance Suppressor T cell activity. Both of these events are necessary for pregnancy to be successful. IVIg has been used to successfully treat women with elevated circulating levels of NK cells, NK cell killing activity and embryotoxins with live birth rates between 70% and 80%.

IVIg has also been used to treat women with unexplained repeat pregnancy loss. Four randomized, controlled trials of IVIg for treatment of repeat pregnancy loss have been published. A European-based study showed a positive trend but did not achieve statistical significance due to too few patients for adequate statistical power given the magnitude of the effect. However, a US-based trial did show a significant benefit, the difference in live birth rates being 62% among women receiving IVIg and 33% among women receiving placebo. The greater magnitude of effect in the US-based study than the European-based trial could have arisen from the use of a different study design. Patients began IVIg treatment before conception in the US-based trial, but after implantation in the European-based trial. By waiting until 5-8 weeks of pregnancy to begin treatment, women with NK cell-related pathology occurring earlier would have been excluded and those pregnancies destined to succeed would be included, providing an opportunity for selection bias. Indeed, a negative correlation with delay in treatment was significant in this study. A third trial treated only women who had a previous live birth, a group that showed no significant benefit of treatment using leukocyte immunization, but significant benefit from IVIg. The fourth Canadian-based trial had too few patients for adequate statistical power to give significant results but did show a trend toward benefit in women with a history of previous live birth followed by recurrent miscarriage. When the results of all of these trials were combined in a meta-analysis the conclusion showed IVIg to be effective treatment for repeat pregnancy loss. None of the studies took into account the pregnancies lost as a result of chromosomal abnormalities except the US-based trial. Approximately 60% of the pregnancies lost in the clinical trial would be expected to have chromosomal abnormalities that would not be corrected by IVIg.

The usual dosage of IVIg for treatment of repeat post-implantation pregnancy loss is 25 grams but successful pregnancies have been reported using dosages from 20 to 60 grams. The half-life in circulation is 28 days so infusions are usually given every 28days. Depending on the obstetric history, IVIg is continued every 28 days until the end of the first trimester (women with a history of first trimester pregnancy losses) or until 28-32 weeks gestation (women with a history of late pregnancy losses). Pregnancies are monitored with immunologic blood tests and treatment can be modified based on the results of the blood tests.

Side effects of treatment with IVIg include nausea, vomiting, headaches, chills, chest pain, difficulty breathing—all comfort side effects which usually occur during the infusion of IVIg and are related to the rate of infusion. If these side effects occur, the rate of the infusion of IVIg is slowed. Other side effects that have been reported much less frequently are migraine-type headaches and sore or stiff neck occurring from one to four days after the infusion. Last, but not least, while IVIg is a purified protein particulate that is reconstituted in fluid and infused in veins, the protein is extracted from human plasma. Therefore, it runs the same theoretic risks for transmittable disease as other blood products. However, IVIg has been available on the American market under FDA and CDC surveillance since 1981, with no reported instance of HIV transmission. There were reports of cases of hepatitis C after IVIg treatment reported in 1992 and the first part of 1993 for which some manufactures changed the method of extraction and added a detergent solubilization step. Thus the theoretic risk at this time is an unknown risk of transmission of presently unidentified infectious particles. Because of the rigorous screening it must undergo, the cost of IVIg is high. The high cost of IVIg therapy can be a deterrent to treatment for some individuals.

2. Intralipid

Evidence from both animal and human studies suggest that intralipid administered intravenously may enhance implantation and maintenance of pregnancy. Intralipid is a 20% intravenous fat emulsion used routinely as a source of fat and calories for patients requiring parental nutrition. It is composed of 10% soybean oil, 1.2% egg yolk phospholipids, 2.25% gylcerine and water. Intralipid stimulated the immune system to remove “danger signals” that can lead to pregnancy loss. The appeal of Intralipid lies in the fact that it is relatively inexpensive and is not a blood product. Its likely benefit to IVF patients with immunologic dysfunction is under evaluation.

3. Aspirin

Low-dose aspirin (80mg or 1 baby aspirin) alone has used for treatment of recurrent post-implantation pregnancy losses. Among women with increased resistance of blood flow through their uterine arteries who were treated with aspirin for a minimum of two weeks, the pregnancy rate was increased from 17% to 47% after IVF/ET and the miscarriage rate decreased from 60% to 15%. As a prostaglandin inhibitor, aspirin would be expected to increase blood flow to the ovary prior to implantation, to the endometrium during implantation and to prevent clotting of the placental vessels following implantation. However, in studies of women experiencing recurrent post-implantation pregnancy loss/miscarriage associated with antiphospholipid antibodies, results of clinical trials have shown aspirin alone to be half as effective as other treatments including heparin and steroids. In two studies women receiving aspirin alone or heparin plus aspirin for treatment of repeat pregnancy loss associated with antiphospholipid antibodies, heparin plus aspirin provided a significantly better outcome that aspirin alone (live birth rate of 80% vs 44%).

A rationale for the use of low-dose aspirin therapy during pregnancy for women with antiphospholipid antibodies is to decrease blood clots from forming in the placental vessels. The mechanisms by which aspirin prevents blood clots are through its antiprostaglandin and antiprostacyclin effects and inhibition of platelet adhesiveness and aggregation.

4. Heparin

Heparin has also been used in conjunction with aspirin to prevent blood clotting. The rational for using heparin is that it is a blood thinner and inhibits clot formation by a different pathway that the aspirin. While the effectiveness of heparin and aspirin for treatment of women with elevated circulating antiphospholipid antibodies and a history of recurrent miscarriage is well accepted, the use of heparin with or without aspirin to enhance implantation rates has been controversial. Most clinical trials of women with elevated antiphospholipid antibodies and a history of implantation failure undergoing IVF/ET show no enhancement of implantation rates with heparin and aspirin compared with no treatment. This observation is not surprising since the action of heparin is on the cells lining the blood vessels and pre- and peri- implantation pregnancy loss occurs before placental blood vessels appear. The combination of both heparin and aspirin given to women experiencing repeat pregnancy loss who had antiphospholipid antibodies are associated with a live birth rate of 80% compared with a live birth rate of 44% in women receiving aspirin alone. Live birth rates with heparin, aspirin and a steroid called prednisone are 74%. Thus no enhancement of live birth rates are noticed when prednisone is added to heparin and aspirin therapy for treatment of recurrent miscarriage.

Heparin is usually administered at a dose of 5,000-10,000 units subcutaneous twice a day along with aspirin 80mg each day. In women with a circulating lupus-like anticoagulant, more heparin may be required. The side effects of heparin therapy include bleeding, decreased platelet count and osteoporosis or thinning of the bones. Calcium supplementation (two tablets of Tums a day) is recommended while taking heparin. Low molecular weight heparins such as Lovenox and Fragmin have also been used to treat recurrent pregnancy loss associated with thrombophilias, either acquired or inherited.

5. Steroids

Historically, repeat pregnancy loss associated with antiphospholipid antibodies was treated with combinations of prednisone and aspirin. The rationale for prednisone therapy is suppression of autoantibodies such as antiphospholipid and antinuclear antibodies. A study comparing live birth rates in women treated with heparin and aspirin with prednisone and aspirin showed 75% live births in both groups. However, both maternal complications and preterm delivery with premature rupture of membranes and toxemia of pregnancy were significantly higher in pregnant women treated with prednisone and aspirin compared with heparin and aspirin. Other side effects of steroid medication include fluid retention, weight gain, and mood changes. Therefore, the current recommendation for “first attempt” treatment for repeat pregnancy loss associated with antiphospholipid antibodies is heparin and aspirin.

6. Host Uterus

If the cause of the recurrent pregnancy loss resides within the uterine environment and if that cause cannot be corrected, then a host uterus may be a final solution for treatment. A host uterus is a uterus donated by a woma n other than the patient. In this situation, embryos are generated using the egg of the patient and sperm of her husband through in vitro fertilization (IVF). The embryos thus generated are transferred into the uterus of the host. The intention is that the host will achieve pregnancy with the patients’ embryos, carry the pregnancy to term and, upon delivery, return the babies to the genetic parents.
 

 

The IVF Institute-Chicago
Notice of Privacy Practices
Disclaimer
Copyright © 2004-2009

Infertility website development and promotion by IHR

Infertility Resources
InfertilityBooks.com
VasectomyReversalSpecialists.com
InfertilityProfessionals.com